Dispelling their False Logic on AM Revolution

Date: Wed, 3 Dec 2008 23:44:06 To: AM-GLOBAL Subject: Dispelling their False Logic on AM Revolution From: "Ishvara" Baba "A'lor pathik ese geche tamah na'shiya'..." (P.S. 467) Purport: The almighty Parama Purusa, the Traveler of divine effulgence has come and all the darkness has vanished by His august advent. The lethargy, drowsiness & staticity have gotten destroyed. The wall & gate of the jail have been smashed by His grace. In a flash-- in a blink of an eye-- He has destroyed the dogma and crudeness which has accumulated since hundreds of years. All the clouds of dilemma have been removed. Now all around the effulgence is spreading and floating in all the directions. O' my friends, family members, brothers and sisters, please do not remain distant and away. Do not keep yourself separate and alien. Please come close. Sing and dance with the happiness of the infinite attraction and inspiration of His divine vibration...

== DISPELLING THEIR FALSE LOGIC ON AM REVOLUTION ==

Namaskar, All know that the AM Revolution discourse was distorted by deleting the paragraph about margii rights Even then, various groupist agents attempt to justify the matter in various tricky ways. But here in this letter is one point which they cannot defend-- not at all.

WHAT IS THEIR JUSTIFICATION

As we have seen time and again, the top-level justification given by some groupist Dadas is that "everything that appears in our AM books has been approved by Baba". This is their final reply to quell the matter and permanently shut the mouth of all who question them about the distortion done to the AM Revolution discourse. In recurring email discussions, this has been the final reply given by various factional agents.

NEW POINT: NOT EVERYTHING IN AM BOOKS HAS BEEN APPROVED BY BABA

But here is one point which tears down their entire silly justification about the distortion done to AM Revolution, where they falsely tell that Baba has approved such changes because it got printed in the book. In the post 1990 period, various reigning groupists distorted Caryacarya part 1 in order to manipulate the Purodha Board membership. I.e. they intentionally changed Baba's words in order to put forth their devious political agenda. And below all the details about this are discussed and proven. So this act of distortion to CC-1 shows that for their self-interest various groupists cunningly make their own insertions and changes. Given this, then who can believe them that (a) "everything in our AM Books has been approved by Baba" and that (b) the distortion to AM Revolution was approved by Baba. So the distortion done to the Purodha Board chapter in Caryacarya part 1-- which we are going to examine now-- is a key point in the AM Revolution distortion case. Because the distortion done to CC-1 shows that for their groupist agenda they are willing to do anything: Including distorting Baba's holy scripture without His approval.

BACKGROUND BEHIND DISTORTION DONE TO AM REVOLUTION AND CARYACARYA PART 1

Firstly, as their justification about AM Revolution distortion get exposed and as we unearth the distortion done to the Caryacarya Part 1, it is needed to take a brief look at the events leading up to this dark episode about the change to the Purodha Board chapter in CC-1. Everybody knows that in 1990 Sarvatmanandji's eye was towards grabbing and consolidating all the power in AM. Yet at the same time he knew he needed to go about it in a deliberate and psychological way. Otherwise the whole thing would erupt and blow up in his face. So in his selected approach, from 1990 Sarvatmanandji kept the chair of GS for himself, as he felt this would give him maximum power; and, side by side, so as not to rock the boat, he knew he needed to insert a Hindi speaking person as the PP. Hence the arrival of Shraddhanandji onto the scene. For the most part PP was just a tool in Sarvatmanandji's hand. But it was not at all a guarantee that it would always be like this. After all who can predict the future. So to safeguard his power and ensure that he could always overrule the PP, Sarvatmanandji made one key distortion to Caryacarya regarding the Purodha Board. And indeed the following details about this distortion stand as proof that not all that appears in our AM books has been approved by Baba, in which case they cannot use that as their chief defense in the distortion done to AM Revolution.

THE ACTUAL DISTORTION DONE TO CARYACARYA-1 ('91 EDN)

Here are the nutshell details about the distortion done to CC-1, which of course is all interlinked with the distortion done to AM Revolution. Sarvatmananda knew that the post of PP play a major role. Everyone knows that it is Baba's standard policy that there are 4 persons on the Purodha Board, including PP who is the chairperson. So in order to tilt the political scene in his favour, Sarvatmananda altered the 1991 Edition of CC-1 by adding a FIFTH person onto the Purodha Board. Because by simple mathematics he knew that the more people are on the PB board the less impact PP's vote has. In that case PP's stance gets watered down-- diminished. For this reason Sarvatmananda distorted chapter 40 of the 1991 edition of Caryacarya part 1 by stating, "The Purodhas will elect the FIVE members of the Purodha Board". That is why if you look at any copy of CC-1 '91 Edn, you will find that it says "FIVE members of the Purodha Board" on the second paragraph of page 79. So this was how Sarvatmananda and distorted Baba's scripture. Means Sarvatmananda actually got his own wrong words printed in our AM books. Proof being that the '91 Edition of CC-1 says, "FIVE members of the Purodha Board". And no one can sit back and say that Baba approves of such changes. Because it is well established per Baba's direction that the Purodha Board should consist of 4 members, not 5.

PROOF THAT IT WAS DONE DELIBERATELY

And further proof that this distortion was done deliberately is that there was a big fight in Centre back in 1994 about this. Back then the newly formed H group led by Rudrananda was vehemently opposing this fake Purodha board point. Because they feared that by this way Sarvatmananda would control the PP and rule with his iron fist forever and ever. So a big clash erupted over this distortion done to CC-1, with each side strongly sticking to their agenda. Here the point is that neither party was interested in upholding Baba's teaching and neither party was interested in keeping the scripture pristine. Rather both sides were fighting over the control of the organisation. So it was not just a simple innocent mistake. If it were, then one side would apologise for the error and thereafter all would work together. But it was not like this. Instead both groups were fighting for control over the organisation-- and the intentional change to CC-1 was a major factor in this. So just as we see their distortion was done to CC-1 in deliberate fashion, the same type of fight and justification we see going on now with regards to the AM-Revolution discourse. In order to get unbridled control of the organisation the various WT groups want the paragraph about margii rights to be permanently deleted.

GROUPIST COUNTER-ATTACK: THE DETAILS HOW CC-1 GOT SWITCHED BACK

Here is more of this history of the distortion done to CC-1 and how it relates to their fake campaign about AM Revolution. When the H group faction started to come into existence in the mid-90's, they had growing animosity towards Sarvatmananda's Bengali regime. And those H group people knew that Sarvatmananda's plan was to strangle them. So when they saw the way in which Sarvatmananda distorted CC-1 by changing the number of Purodha Board members, then the H group personnel knew this could bury them. Because PP was the main Hindi speaking agent at the top and if his vote got watered down on the Purodha Board, then B group would easily grab all the power. So the situation was dire for Rudrananda and his H faction. Then with one big blow they pressured Sarvatmananda with all their might. And they gathered the evidence and proved that Purodha Board should consist of four members, not FIVE. In result, that distorted point about FIVE members on the Purodha Board got discarded. Because out of their group interest, the H faction had it removed. That is why the 1995 edition of CC-1 states that there are FOUR members on the Purodha Board, NOT FIVE. So with the CC-1 controversy, the distortion went against the interest of one of the WT groups. That is why the distortion got "fixed". Whereas with the AM Revolution distortion, all the WT groups favour this point: They all want the margiis suppressed. So they are happy to keep the distortion which eliminates the paragraph about margii rights. All this goes to show two things: (1) That not all the things printed in AM books have been approved by Baba; and (2) Groupist wts will not "fix" any distortion that goes in their favour.

TODAY'S DIALOGUE ABOUT AM REVOLUTION

Now today then, as the discussion whirls & swirls around about the distortion done to the 'Ananda Marga: A Revolution' discourse, margiis are raising the right questions and certain Dadas are desperately fumbling around giving an array of half-baked answers. This is the way the scene is unfolding. Indeed, certain Dadas loudly proclaim that whatever appears in our AM books has been done with the expressed approval of Baba. This is one of their favourite justifications which they give-- all done to shut the mouths of margiis validate whatever scriptural distortions those Dadas make, such as the deletion of the historic paragraph about margii rights in the 'AM Revolution' discourse. So in their parrot-like approach, those Dadas just repeat again and again that everything that has been inserted or deleted in our AM books was done per Baba's direction. This is their default reply. But as we have seen above regarding the point of CC-1, it is clear that their justification is totally fake and baseless. It is not at all true that all the chapters in our AM books are done with Baba's approval. Because just as the changed the number of member on the Purodha Board in CC-1, similarly they deleted the paragraph about Margii rights in the AM Revolution discourse. And neither change was done with Baba's approval. Both are a case of clear-cut deliberate distortion. But the point from CC-1 got "repaired" due to a clash between the two WT factions whereas to this day the distortion done to the AM Revolution discourse is being defended by all the Group leaders-- because the point goes according to their power hungry way of thinking.

SUMMARY

So when any groupist Dada says that Baba has approved of all that appears in the AM books and that therefore the change to AM Revolution is proper, then we know that what that type of Dada is telling is hogwash-- totally false. Because when those same groupists did not like what CC-1 stated, then they changed that. And same is the case with the distortion done to the AM Revolution discourse. They did not like the paragraph in the AM Revolution discourse about margii rights so they intentionally deleted that historic paragraph-- without Baba's approval. So this their proven working style. So none should be befooled by their silly justification that everything which appears in our AM books has Baba's expressed approval. It is not like that.

BABA'S BLESSING

By Baba's grace the day is not far when all His scriptures will be in their original and perfect condition and our AM society will grow accordingly-- i.e in a neo-humanistic way, free from all group interest. Baba says, "The human race is moving at an irresistible speed. Today, humanity wants to forget those who have written their works centering around various kinds of fissiparous discriminations. Human beings want to channelize their whole range of vision towards the bright future - a future which will transcend all individual or group interests, all territorial limits of countries and states, and transform the fates of many people into one destiny." (PNS-10) Namaskar, Ishvara

Note 1: MORE DETAILS ABOUT THE CC-1 DISTORTION WHY SARVATMANANDA DID IT

Everyone knows that it is Baba's standard policy that there are 4 persons on the Purodha Board, including PP who is the chairperson. And it is also commonly known that if three members of the Purodha Board vote in one direction and PP votes in the opposite direction, then those three members get victory. This Baba has carefully and clearly outlined in Caryacarya (chapter 40). So although the post of PP is extremely powerful in AMPS, there is a way to overrule PP-- and this Sarvatmanandji understood. But he also understood that getting a 3 to 1 victory over PP every time will not always be easy. And if the vote ends up 2-2 then PP's side wins. Being aware about all this, Sarvatmanandji knew he needed to water down PP's power. This was absolutely needed. So this is what Sarvatmanandji did.

Note 2: NOT UNINTENTIONAL

Nor can anyone sit back and say that the change to Caryacarya was just "an honest mistake", unintentional. No one can say like this because not even the most naive personwill believe such justification. Because anyone can easily understand that the number of people on the Purodha Board is a potentially politically loaded statement. So if one power mongerer changes that figure and none of Baba's other original words are distorted in the entire book, then who is going to believe that changing the number of members on the Purodha Board is just "an honest mistake". Not only that when the matter was raised back in 1994 then Sarvatmananda struggled tooth and nail to defend the point, but ultimately he lost.

Note 3: THE CENTRAL MATTER IS THE AM REVOLUTION DISCOURSE

The key point of this entire letter is that groupists will go to extreme measures to get the power. They will distort Baba's books and they will give all kinds of justifications about this. And this is what we are witnessing with regards to the distortion done to the AM Revolution discourse. But we should not give in to their false logic. With the facts in hand we should stand tall and in Baba's holy name demand that the integrity of His teachings be restored and the distortion done to the AM Revolution discourse should be fixed.

*************************************************** Food Resources-- Ocean Bed

Baba says. "Through oceanographic research humanity has discovered a vast treasure of food resources within the ocean and on the sea bed. With the application of science and technology, we can explore these resources to meet the challenge of the food problem." (PNS-13, p.47)

***************************************************